Skip to content

suckless software

  • https://suckless.org/
  • Suckless software generally embodies low entropy compared to many mainstream software systems.

Low-Entropy Characteristics of Suckless Software

  1. Minimalism in Design

  2. The software is designed to do one thing well, avoiding unnecessary features or complexity that would add disorder.

  3. Clean and Understandable Codebase

  4. Small codebases with a focus on clarity make it easier for developers to understand and modify the software. This reduces unpredictability.

  5. No Hidden Layers or Dependencies

  6. By minimizing dependencies and abstractions, suckless software avoids the complexity often introduced by layers of middleware or third-party libraries.

  7. Hackability and Direct Configuration

  8. Configuration via source code rather than complex configuration files ensures that all changes are explicit and controlled, minimizing the chances of hidden side effects.

  9. Adherence to Unix Philosophy

  10. Building small, composable tools reduces interdependency and the cascading complexity seen in monolithic systems.

Why Suckless Software Has Low Entropy

Entropy in software often arises from:

  • Feature Creep: Suckless avoids this by adhering to minimalism.
  • Complex Interactions: Suckless tools are designed to be simple and modular.
  • Poor Maintenance: The clean and well-documented codebases of suckless projects make maintenance straightforward.

By focusing on simplicity, efficiency, and clarity, suckless software minimizes the sources of entropy that plague many modern systems.

When Suckless Might Have Higher Entropy

While generally low-entropy, there are cases where suckless software could approach higher entropy:

  • User-Introduced Complexity: If users add excessive customizations or poorly thought-out patches to the source code.
  • Lack of Documentation: Some suckless tools rely heavily on users understanding the code themselves, which could create confusion or errors for less experienced developers.

In summary, suckless software is intentionally designed to have relatively low entropy, making it an excellent choice for those who value simplicity and control over their systems.

  • from chatgpt

Suckless Software refers to a philosophy and a community-driven set of projects aimed at producing minimal, simple, and efficient software. The term comes from the idea of creating software that "sucks less" than bloated or overly complex alternatives.

Core Principles of Suckless Software

  1. Simplicity
  2. Prioritizing simplicity in design, code, and functionality.

  3. Avoiding unnecessary features or abstractions.

  4. Minimalism

  5. Creating lightweight software with minimal dependencies.

  6. Keeping the codebase small and understandable.

  7. Efficiency

  8. Ensuring the software is resource-efficient and performs well even on older or less powerful systems.

  9. Hackability

  10. Emphasizing user customization by providing clean, easily modifiable source code instead of complex configuration files.

  11. Unix Philosophy

  12. Following principles like "do one thing and do it well" and leveraging small, composable tools.

Examples of Suckless Software

  1. dwm (Dynamic Window Manager)
  2. A minimalistic tiling window manager for X11.

  3. Configured by editing its source code directly.

  4. st (Simple Terminal)

  5. A lightweight terminal emulator designed to be a simple alternative to bloated terminal programs.

  6. surf

  7. A minimalist web browser that relies on WebKitGTK, with a focus on simplicity.

  8. sbase and ubase

  9. Minimalistic replacements for Unix core utilities, focusing on simplicity and essential functionality.

  10. slstatus

  11. A simple status monitor for window managers like dwm.

Why People Like Suckless Software

  • Control: Editing the source code allows users to tailor the software to their exact needs.
  • Efficiency: Works well on low-resource systems or for users who prioritize performance.
  • Philosophy: Appeals to users who value the Unix philosophy and dislike modern software bloat.

Criticism or Challenges

  1. Steep Learning Curve

  2. Requires users to be comfortable editing and compiling source code.

  3. Limited Features

  4. Minimalism sometimes sacrifices features that some users might find essential.

  5. Developer-Centric

  6. Designed with developers or advanced users in mind, making it less accessible for casual users.

  7. Lack of Community Resources

  8. Limited documentation or tutorials compared to larger, mainstream projects.

If you're interested in exploring or using suckless software, their official website, suckless.org, provides source code and resources.

High-entropy software

  • from chatgpt
  • typically exhibits significant complexity, disorder, and unpredictability in its structure or behavior. This can arise due to various factors, including poor design, lack of maintenance, or evolving requirements. Here are some examples and characteristics:

Characteristics of High-Entropy Software

  1. Spaghetti Code
  2. Code that is tangled, lacks structure, and is difficult to follow or modify.

  3. Often results from ad-hoc additions without proper refactoring.

  4. High Technical Debt

  5. Features implemented with shortcuts, leading to code that's fragile or hard to scale.

  6. Accumulated over time without addressing foundational improvements.

  7. Poor Documentation

  8. Lack of clear documentation makes understanding and modifying the software difficult.

  9. Contributes to uncertainty about how components interact.

  10. Legacy Systems

  11. Systems built with outdated technologies or practices, often patched over decades without holistic redesigns.

  12. Developers are reluctant to change critical components, leading to "workarounds" that increase entropy.

  13. Complex Dependencies

  14. Extensive interdependencies between components, making changes ripple unpredictably through the system.

  15. Examples include monolithic architectures or systems with poorly defined APIs.

  16. Frequent Bugs and Unintended Behaviors

  17. A sign of entropy is the inability to predict how changes will affect other parts of the system.

Examples of High-Entropy Software

  1. Unmaintained Legacy Software

  2. Old banking systems or healthcare software running on mainframes with minimal updates to core logic.

  3. Overengineered Systems

  4. Applications with unnecessary abstractions, excessive modularization, or redundant functionality that adds to complexity.

  5. Rapid Prototyping Turned Production

  6. Applications initially designed as prototypes but later scaled for production without refactoring, leading to fragile systems.

  7. Open Source Projects with Multiple Contributors

  8. Projects with no clear coding standards or central architectural guidance often grow into high-entropy systems.

  9. Custom ERP or CRM Solutions

  10. Enterprise software designed to accommodate specific business needs, often leading to convoluted configurations and codebases.

Why Is High-Entropy Software Problematic?

  • Harder Maintenance: Small changes may require disproportionate effort or cause unexpected issues.
  • Reduced Performance: Inefficiencies accumulate as the system grows in complexity.
  • Scalability Challenges: High entropy makes it harder to adapt to increased demand or new technologies.
  • Increased Risk: Debugging, testing, and deploying become more prone to errors.

Managing Software Entropy

To reduce entropy, practices such as regular refactoring, adherence to coding standards, proper documentation, automated testing, and modular design are essential.